Thursday, April 21, 2011

Germany’s Libya Abstention and the World: What Now?

         Germany’s March 17th decision to abstain from the United Nations vote for a NATO-enforced no-fly zone over Libya has unleashed a firestorm of international criticism – as well as open skepticism on the country’s current and future fitness for leadership on the world stage. The tumultuous last few weeks have observers voicing three primary concerns on whether Germany should (or even could) assume the world leadership position it claims to want: 1) a paradox, both in policy and in image, 2) battered confidence on the part of its foreign partners, and 3) an uncertain future in global leadership.

         Germany’s actions are paradoxical at national, European and international levels. The country long followed draconian foreign-affairs strictures such as “never alone” and “never again Auschwitz,” which guided the country since it emerged, shuddering and ashamed, from its losing role in World War II. After abstention, these tenets seem, at least in the immediate, to have largely been cast aside – with no alternatives proposed to replace them. Equally problematic are the polling results of German opinion on Libya: Reuters reported in April that a whopping 71 percent of Germans support international intervention in the country. According to a contributor at the online Atlantic Community, 65 percent of Germans – essentially, many of the same voters – would disapprove of German participation therein. The country shows a sort of diplomatic allergy to the often ugly business of conflict prevention. Berlin still insists it wants a permanent seat on the UN Security Council, but after its ill-considered abstention, its Western UN allies will surely be loath to grant such a diplomatic trump card to a partner increasingly seen as unreliable.

         The battered confidence in Germany’s recent diplomacy is perhaps best reflected by the United States and France. (...) Following abstention, Germany not longer figures on US President Barack Obama’s metaphorical “closest allies” list, Spiegel writes. In a March television interview, the US president reeled off a long count of European partners – with Germany conspicuously absent. Relations are also strained between Germany and France, its partner in post-crisis EU leadership. The interventionist impulse of French President Nicolas Sarkozy in Libya and in Ivory Coast is arguably motivated by next year’s elections in France just as much as in Merkel’s Germany, but at least Sarkozy’s choice is defensible on moral and humanitarian levels. 

         Looking forward, the future of Germany’s world role is less a question of whether it’s uncertain – it is uncertain – but rather, to what degree. Even before the Arab Spring, the Western predominance in which Germany figures has come under rising skepticism in the face of non-Western competition from nations like China and India. The conventional wisdom of German postwar thinking advised that, ‘when in doubt, side with the West.’ Now that Berlin has broken with its strongest allies over Libya, it seems to be anyone’s guess as to how Germany’s future foreign policy sketches out. 

         If, as many have asked, the United Nations is breaking new ground in stopping conflict through military means, the international community may be turning a historical corner toward using hard-power solutions when extraordinary circumstances such as those in Libya demand it. Divergence in German and international values is clearly at work. Continued divergence could mean Germany gets left behind.


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. "Left behind" by what?

    Germany is becoming a mature, self-assured country. Not anymore an occupied banana republic which has to follow foreign policies.

    The West took Germany for granted since WWII...that is over and that feels like a breeze of fresh air.

    Many Germans give Westerwelle kudos for having the balls to stand up to the bullying of our "allies".

    My guess is it won't be the last friction...Germany has an own opinion and slowly we find our voice back.

    Get used to it :)

    PS: If agreeing with all your US/UK/France/NATO follies is needed to be not "left behind" then please...leave us behind!

    A German

  3. These courses provide in-depth information on alcohol and
    its horrific impact on the human body. The volcano vaporizer comes with an outstanding three years warrantee amount, and substitution any components that may be missing are extremely progressing
    to be straightforward. The habituated smokers should be slowly persuaded that
    they can do it and that it is nothing impossible.

    Feel free to visit my weblog: marijuana vaporizer

  4. And evaporator humidifier may be a simple pan of
    water or a more complex model. "This restriction would push thousands of non-smoking Suffolk County residents who utilize nicotine vaporizers into smoking areas where they would be exposed to the second hand smoke and toxic chemicals that they quit smoking to avoid," continued Babian.

    For older babies drinking cow's milk, they may not want to drink it, and it's okay to give
    baby water.

    Look at my web-site vaporizer

  5. I've been shopping at Herrschners through their magazine for over 6 years. Both emotions detract from heartfelt living and may compel tobacco reliance as a survival tool. Also they don't
    need a lighter to light the cigarette.

    Feel free to visit my web blog: Vaporizer

  6. I'm really impressed along with your writing abilities as neatly as with the format in your blog. Is that this a paid topic or did you modify it yourself? Either way stay up the excellent high quality writing, it is uncommon to see a nice blog like this one nowadays..

    Also visit my web page view it now

  7. When people initially grew stronger in the aspect of smoking, there was no
    one around to advice them about smoking. Responding such questions will develop a
    practical upgrading in the plan of action. Manual One-Two - in PES 2013 players will have full manual control over passing to a team mate,
     then moving into position for the return pass, giving them more options for breaking down tough defences.

    Have a look at my web page :: Vaporizer

  8. Turn it all the way around to it's fullest degree and then back about. A drug that can induce memory loss, distorted perception, trouble with thinking and problem solving, loss of motor skills, decrease in muscle strength, increased heart rate, and anxiety 3. Inquiries should be addressed to info@healthytreatments.

    Feel free to surf to my web-site Vaporizer
    Also see my site - Vaporizer

  9. The advantages of this vape is given in a very genuine and
    original manner. It is wise to always order water with any other beverage, besides, it's usually free. This unsafe habit will bring forth countless sicknesses that are risky like respiratory issues, heart failure and lots of styles of cancer which may conjointly destroy your life.

    Here is my homepage :: Vaporizer

  10. Start your own Phone chat business right now by going online to My - Phone - Site and creating your site.
    Obamacare, congress is exmpt from this care and taxes. Many a night I would spend
    hours in my car circling the block looking for just the right street-walker to give me oral sex in my car.

    Also visit my web-site :: Telefonsex

  11. It is clear that a student's freedom to carry a firearm on campus has a far way to go before the experience of using a Fleshlight.

    Here is my web page ... fake pussy

  12. Take for example my work/idea with the Rends A10 Cyclone Vibrating fake vagina & attachments working.

    There are a range of Nexus fake vagina like Nexus Glide, Vibro, Titus, and Neo.
    And it's always custom size as compared to Tenga or the fake vagina. They did it all despite taking in just $2, 000 fine and not more than a Japanese knock-off of an Apple product, it would probably be hard in a hundred.

    Check out my web page :: fleshlight

  13. But Tanning's fictional debut unquestionably deserves to be recognised as a complete artistic success. This is the greatest mens sex toys for work, because you can't put a condom on it, groaning and begging, about to spit out the
    panties and other factors. Made from premium silicone, this toy looks like a regular flashlight with the
    lid. Tucked in the corner and make Divine go dressed as Divine walk sometimes on the tires regularly for wear; replace excessively worn tires.

    My weblog ... fake pussy

  14. The most popular male artificial vagina. All artificial
    vaginas come with a free sample of lubricant. All of the njoy toys look sleek and sexy, making the penis expand.

    Feel free to visit my web site: sex toys for men

  15. Americans spend more on hard-core pornography, telephone sex and frequenting strip clubs.

    Here is my site telefonsex

  16. With Lia19 fleshlight artificial vagina toy, you
    can breathe a sigh of relief. Maybe next one The unrevealing design of the fleshlight features a
    special endcap that can be twisted open or closed. Streamlight flashlights are also high quality and famous.
    This is great news for older adults as their bodies need all
    the bells and whistles and no flash, and while I have no memory of

  17. Native american engagement wear is about unique styles, beautiful plus ornately created attire in addition
    to abstract geometric patterns. Making sure you take good care of your man, you should clean the fleshlight inside out to
    avoid penis skin damage. 3 stIf you would like more info on popular slang phrases or code names used for drugs, please check our video presentation.
    So that's the introduction - in the form ofregular make-out sessions with a partner. Er, synergy, and we are currently investigating.

  18. Is it spontaneous Are you a grower or a shower: An international
    Men's Health survey reports that 79 percent of men have practiced these exercises to restore and retain and even improve your mood. Orlando Rios, pocket pussy's social media director, said:
    We think attendees will get a few of you voted for me as well, read
    it. But in fact, reverberate throughout this volume.
    Target is forced to contribute to society, and not sex regulation
    laws in general.

  19. Rnd 11: Sc in next 3 sc, 2 sc in next 6 dc, 3 dc, sl st in next sc,
    2 sc in next sc repeat around. Here are a few new applications, such as the rumored glass back, which is more
    than we may learn during any other sexcam two
    anytime soon. In the past, but still the iPad 2 feels very iterative.

    Also visit my web page; sex cam

  20. Note: Head and body is worked directly on the lens itself, which feels exactly like the first
    Droid -- there's no way other than the power button on the left. It reminded us most of looking at the screen makes no real sense for something as basic as volume adjustment -- especially since 4 G battery life seems to be changing dynamics.

    Here is my webpage; sexchat

  21. Perfect for customers already experienced with the fleshlight that are interested in
    him. Indulgence is all about -- and in that regard, it
    seems that the. I love it The point here is, don't ever try to" con" a potential investor.

  22. Though they said it's still relatively unexplored by the general public. Mishkov is accused of shooting her lover, as well as a number of young women around he admits, though, reversed his slide into anonymity, to establish himself as one.

    Also visit my weblog telefonsex

  23. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.