Tidbits on Libya and the EU

A brief from EUobserver reports that on May 26 Hadeiba Hadi, the Libyan Ambassador to the EU, defected from his post as representative of the Qaddafi regime in Brussels. His staff also resigned.

In a statement made to the AFP, Hadi explained that he and his team felt obliged to make a decision to "no longer represent the regime," which is currently embattled against rebel forces seeking to ouster the Libyan leader from his decades-long rule.

Speaking of EU-Libyan affairs, last week EU foreign affairs chief Lady Catherine Ashton opened an EU office in Benghazi, Libya, where rebel governing structures like the Transitional National Council (TNC) are based. In a statement made following a meeting with the TNC's Chairman, Mustafa Abdul Jalil, Ashton promised EU partnership in policy areas including security, economy, health, education and civil society. 

The EU's move to set up shop in Benghazi marks perhaps the boldest diplomatic decision for Libya's long haul. This takes one step further the decision by French president Nicolas Sarkozy to be the first to recognize the Libyan rebels' legitimacy. Much remains to be seen in the development of a Libya without Qaddafi in charge -- and even this, though desired by much of the international community, is a far-from-certain outcome. 

In an unexpected result from the G8 conference currently taking place in Deauville, France, Russian president Dimitri Medvedev has offered to try to coax Qaddafi into stepping down. This seems like an unreliable hand-off of negotiating power should the decision-makers in Europe and the US decide to go with it. But it may allow Russia to assert itself as a key player in conflict resolution, while the EU and US would benefit from some much-needed relief to then focus on issues closer to home such as the ongoing euro crisis and global recession more broadly. More to follow.

Ashton, Clinton Meet -- Washington Snoozes

EEAS chief Lady Catherine Ashton and US Sectretary of State Hilary Clinton met in Washington Tuesday to discuss a buffet of global issues, notably Syria in the context of the Arab Spring uprisings that have rocked the Middle East and North Africa since December 2010. 

A random Google search revealed that, apart from CNN, no major US news networks or print outlets thought the event was worth covering. Meanwhile, transatlantic coverage continues to be dominated by the Arab Spring, late-phase details in the Osama Bin Laden execution, US relations with Pakistan and the Cannes Film Festival and, most recently, the scandal surrounding rape allegations against IMF chief Dominique Strauss-Kahn (see previous EurAmerican post).

What does the EEAS -- and the EU more broadly -- have to do to make headlines in Washington?

Bearish and Bullish on the EEAS

The transatlantic commentariat has said much about the early successes and failures of the European External Action Service (EEAS) and its chief, Lady Catherine Ashton. What follows are two diametrically opposed opinions on how EU foreign policy's been doing.

Presseurop's Iulia Badea Guéritée absolutely slams the fledgling agency. Guéritée posts a withering indictment that claims Ashton has been by turns "absent," "voiceless" and the embodiment of timidity in European foreign affairs. 

"The European External Action Service was created over three months ago to provide the EU the unified voice it lacked and its boss, Catherine Ashton has been remarkably…absent. Absent – or overshadowed by other European leaders – in the changing Arab world, absent in Japan, absent in Libya and absent in Lampedusa. What needs to happen for Ms Ashton and the EEAS to come out of the woods?"

Some paint a more rosy picture of the EU's diplomatic strength. Brookings Institute scholar Justin Vaisse counters that European policy heft is being increasingly felt around the world, not least of all according to yardsticks like the European Council on Foreign Relations' "score card" for EU foreign policy effectiveness. (Vaisse played a founding role in the score card's creation.) He writes proudly that

"... The Scorecard seems to be encouraging a discussion about Europe's role and behaviour in the world – our tools, our values and ideals, our interests, our vision. "Policy" is suddenly back in "European foreign policy." "

Chuffed as Vaisse may be to say so, the question of the true gravitas of the EU's global role is the subject of lively discussion worldwide.

Egypt and the European Angle

Here's some of what we in the U.S. may not be seeing in regards to the European response on Egypt:

From Presseurop
 

The European Voice reports that the EU is reconsidering their aid structures to the country, which for the last three weeks has been paralyzed by protesters demanding the ouster of President Hosni Mubarak. Earlier this month EU leaders gathered in Brussels called for a democratic transition 'now,' offering various EU instruments that include "proposals and projects" to assist a post-Mubarak Egypt. The columnist Bruce Stokes underscores the leverage that trade could provide in stabilizing the nation should the current president, who has occupied his seat since 1981, respond to broad calls from his citizens that he step down.

From Le Figaro

Le Figaro describes a furious public after this afternoon's speech by Mubarak, in which the president announced the transfer of his powers without going as far as resigning his office. This article features a fascinating minute-by-minute timeline on the events of the day, from before the speech to the march toward the TV station where Mubarak had delivered his address.  

EUobserver sports a black-and-white dichotomy between in reporting and editorial blogs, with almost zero attention paid to the Egypt conflict in the former, and near-exclusive focus poured onto the Middle Eastern nation. Roberto Foa alludes to the region then segues nicely into a demographic analysis.  George Irvin surmises that, "will Mubarak go? The answer must surely be ‘yes’," before launching into a security debate with an Israeli-Arab orientation.  Nicu Popescu writes on revolutions, European "fence-sitting" as policy and the Egypt uprising's similarities with those in Albania and Belarus.

Presseurop submits that the revolutions across North Africa are only difficultly comparable to the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. On EU-Middle East relations, they say it's "time to ditch the Arab stereotype."

Euronews bring an under-reported angle to the religious climate in Egypt, where Muslims and Coptic Christians are united in solidarity during anti-government protests.

Global Europe illustrates discord between the EU's foreign policy chief, Catherine Ashton, and the Egyptian government, after the latter warned her not to follow through on a planned diplomatic visit later this month. Those close to Ashton say she still plans to arrive in the region, at least to Tunisia.

Watch this space for more on European and US dealings in the ongoing Egyptian turmoil.